A
TOP Sheepdog judge from the popular television programme One
Man and His Dog found himself in a different kind of trial
after he assaulted a fellow dog owner whom he believed had
allowed her animal to attack his cross collie.
Richard Singleton, 48, put a walking stick across the backsides
of both Irene Carroll and Bexley, her Weimaraner, after the
dog attacked his Border Collie Sky, which he was training
to compete at championship level.
The attack last August left Mrs Carroll, a midwife from Manchester,
in shock and in tears and with "significant injuries"
to her left buttock which she claims to still cause her discomfort.
Singleton stormed away with a shout of "Britannia muppets"
when a bystander intervened.
He pleaded guilty last week to assault occasioning actual
bodily harm during a hearing at Minshull Street Crown Court,
Manchester. He was sentenced to 100 hours' community service
and ordered to pay £750 compensation to Mrs Carroll
and £300 costs.
The court heard that Singleton, an international adjudicator
for One Man and His Dog, the BBC sheepdog trials show, had
bought Sky three years ago from champion breeders and was
investing his time and money in training the dog to competition
standard.
He was walking Sky along the River Mersey near Northenden
golf club in Didsbury, Manchester, when he bumped into Mrs
Carroll, who was out with Bexley and Charlie, her sister's
whippet.
Mrs Carroll, 48, put the dogs on their leashes but Bexley
broke free from her grip and lunged at Sky. The two animals
tumbled down a bank until they were separated by Singleton.
Frightened
Lynda
Chapman, prosecuting, said Singleton had then picked up Mrs
Carroll's handcrafted walking stick, which had belonged to
her father, and hit Bexley on the bottom. Mrs Chapman said:
"The defendant was extremely angry, swearing and making
threats. Mrs Carroll was very frightened. His body language
was frightening - he was waving the stick in the air."
Mrs Carroll was kneeling down on the path holding the whippet
when Singleton, still swearing angrily, raised the stickover
his head and struck Mrs Carroll on the buttocks causing a
shooting pain to her leg. Mrs Chapman said: "The fight
was over - there was no need whatsoever."
Singleton began to leave the scene but the incident had been
witnessed by a man on the other side of the canal. He indicated
that he had seen everything, to which Singleton replied: "What
did you see?"
When he told how Mrs Carroll had been hit with a stick, Singleton
said "Britannia muppets", threw the stick away and
left.
Singleton, who has a conviction for wounding 24 years ago,
presented character references to the court, including one
from the lady golf captain at the Northenden club where he
lives and works as a steward.
Sharon Amesu, defending, said: "He reacted in anger to
what he was witnessing. He overreacted in anger after seeing
his significant investment in peril."
Passing sentence, Judge Jeffrey Lewis said he was persuaded
to spare Singleton a jail sentence due to the particular circumstances
of the case and his guilty plea. He said: "You accept
that you deliberately aimed a blow with a stick on the backside
of a lady walking her dog. I accept you lost control on this
day and in the normal course of events are trustworthy, conscientious
and well-regarded."